In this article I want to address the following topics:
- Examples of masculinity and femininity.
- Feminine and masculine work related issues.
- Masculine feminine test.
It is important to realize that I’m looking at feminine and masculine from a national culture point of view. Not from a gender point of view (see further in this article).
If you’re unfamiliar with what feminine and masculine is in the context of national cultural differences, I strongly advise you to read this article. It will give you a clear and concise overview of this cultural dimension.
Masculinity ≠ Gender
In This Article
- 1 Examples of Masculinity and Femininity: Feminine and Masculine Work Related Issues
- 2 Feedback
- 3 Goal Setting versus Growing Insight
- 4 Role Overlap
- 5 Winning versus Participating
- 6 If you’re interested in learning more why not get one of these books?
- 7 Want to Learn More? Why Not Follow a FREE Webinar?
A BIG misunderstanding is that Masculinity (and Femininity on the other side) are linked to Gender differences. That is not the case.
The culture dimension called Masculinity says something about what society expects from people in that society. It says nothing about men or women in particular.
In addition, it gives an indication of the direction of motivation:
- Masculine cultures put more emphasis on the goal and goal achievement.
- Feminine cultures put more emphasis on the process towards the goal and to a lesser extent the goal itself (the road towards the goal is more important than the actual achievement)
Therefore rather than comparing feminine and masculine cultures with each other, you can also say process and goal oriented cultures.
Examples of Masculinity and Femininity: Feminine and Masculine Work Related Issues
First, let’s list the issues where the differences between feminine and masculine cultures are the biggest, then I will give you some examples of masculinity and femininity relating to that list:
- Goal setting versus Growing insight
- Role Overlap
- Winning versus participating.
The first of the examples of masculinity and femininity revolves around feedback.
You can identify 2 forms of feedback: Negative and Positive. Of those two, which is the most prominent?
Most of us will say negative feedback. Most of us get more negative feedback than positive feedback or praise. Agree?
Well for most (if not all) feminine cultures (e.g. Netherlands and Nordic countries), positive feedback is seen as implicit, while explicit positive feedback is seen as suspicious. So if I am too explicit with my positive feedback to a Dutchman, (s)he will think there is something wrong with me and/or that I want something from him or her.
Where Masculine cultures use words like “fantastic, awesome, great, etc“. Feminine cultures will more use words like “nice, fun, ok…”
In addition, from a Feminine cultures’ perspective, giving someone too explicit (and too much) positive feedback might result in the receiver actually thinking he or she “is someone“. In feminine cultures, you are not supposed to stick out or think that you are better than other.
In more Masculine cultures (particularly Anglo-Saxon countries) it is much more expected to receive also positive feedback.
My advice during a cultural awareness training to feminine cultures is to put a post-it note next to their computer reminding them to give positive feedback more explicitly to more masculine cultures.
Goal Setting versus Growing Insight
Another of the examples of Masculinity and Femininity is goal setting versus growing insight.Goal setting being a more Masculine trait, while so-called Growing Insight is much more a Feminine trait. This Growing Insight also supports the cultural need to seek consensus rather than to be (overly) decisive.
Goal setting is a more Masculine trait. The goal is all important. There is even an English saying that illustrates this item: “Get it done, by hook or by crook“.
While so-called Growing Insight is much more a Feminine trait. This Growing Insight also supports the cultural need to seek consensus rather than to make fast decisions.
To put it in an example: Masculine cultures stick to an agreed deadline (e.g. a release date of a piece of software; releasing a Service Pack for the bug fixes later). Feminine cultures rather extend the deadline and solve the bugs now producing a better product from the start.
The next examples of Masculinity and Femininity I’d like to bring up is Role Overlap or Societies expectations of Genders.
Simply put, in more Masculine cultures men put the garbage out and women take care of the kids. There is a greater role differentiation in Masculine cultures than in Feminine cultures.
In Feminine cultures the role overlap is much greater. Men do women’s chores and vice versa.
Examples of this are highly educated Indian women (India scores relatively Masculine). Having finished their education more often than not they end up in well paying very good jobs (in India and abroad). But most, when they are between 25 and 30, feel the pressure (mostly from the family) to quit work and have children.
On the other hand, the percentage of women participating in the labor market (typically with part-time jobs) in the Netherlands (a relatively Feminine culture) is the highest in the world.
Winning versus Participating
The last of the examples of masculinity and femininity is about winning and participating.
Whether it is work related or not, masculine cultures participate in (e.g.) teamwork with the intention to win all the rest is secondary.
Probably you see this coming: feminine cultures participate in (again e.g.) teamwork with the intention to… participate. Joining in is more important than winning (which is achieving a goal).
If you’re interested to see an overview of how other countries score on this dimension of culture, I suggest you take a look here.
Should you wish to read Hofstede’s book with much more examples of Masculinity and Femininity you can get it here.
Comments? Leave them at the end of this post
I have a Master's Degree in Organisational Psychology and have lived in the USA, the Netherlands and, currently, in Belgium.
Latest posts by Chris Smit (see all)
- 069: France and the French; A Danish Perspective with Mathilde Bruun Larsen - 29. November 2016
- 068: The Truth About Nigeria with Odinaka Lavender Ekweremadu - 15. November 2016
- International Business Etiquette; What Country Fits Your Manners? - 10. November 2016